Antitrust damages claims following Brexit: the Federal Court of Justice refers questions to the European Court of Justice
Which courts have jurisdiction over antitrust damages claims when the parties have agreed to submit disputes to the courts of England? The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has considered this question in proceedings concerning the VISA system and referred several questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) for a preliminary ruling.
The claimants are savings banks that are not permitted to charge direct fees at their own ATMs for cash withdrawals made by non-customer cardholders using VISA and VPay cards. They are seeking damages for an alleged infringement of EU competition law. The VISA rules provide for the exclusive jurisdiction of the English courts in disputes relating to the system.
The BGH has doubts as to whether, following Brexit, this jurisdiction clause precludes the German courts from having jurisdiction. The questions also include whether the right to effective judicial protection under EU law is upheld if courts in a third country decide cases involving alleged infringements of EU competition law, as those courts cannot refer questions to the CJEU for a preliminary ruling.
In his article, “Effective Judicial Protection under EU Law in Antitrust Damages Actions after Brexit,” Prof. Dr Ulrich Schnelle analyses the BGH’s decision and its potential implications. The questions referred may have fundamental significance for antitrust disputes involving parties from non-EU countries.
Prof. Dr Ulrich Schnelle, “Effective Judicial Protection under EU Law in Antitrust Damages Actions after Brexit,” GRUR-Prax 21/2026; BGH, order of 17 June 2026 – KZR 29/25 (VISA).